Your Substack Looks Fine. But It's Leaking Subscribers.
Most creators have no idea their newsletter is hemorrhaging potential revenue through default settings they never changed.
FINAL CALL
STOP Leaving Money on the Table
The Substack 360 Coaching Cohort Starts on Tuesday, September 9
Turn your newsletter into multiple revenue streams in 6 weeks. Live group coaching. Only 10 spots. 6 left.
Week 1-2: Subscriber conversion machine + profitable niche
Week 3-4: Digital products that sell
Week 5-6: Partnerships + automated revenueThis isn’t another course to collect dust. It’s Live coaching where we build your portfolio business together.
Next
52 people to join save 50%:$997$498 with code SEPT506 weeks. Real revenue. Limited spots.
Six months ago, I conducted a study of 120 successful Substack publications. It took me weeks, but I noticed that the most successful ones all had one thing in common: They were (mostly) leveraging Substack’s built-in monetization features.
I decided to dig deeper into my publication to see if I could find out how I could make it as engaging as theirs. What I found were at least a dozen features I'd never touched - tools for customizing homepage messages, organizing content for search rankings, and creating strategic navigation.
I spent the next several months implementing and testing every feature. Some worked immediately. Others took some trial and error to get right.
The result? My publication now works like a complete funnel system instead of just newsletter delivery service.
Check my page and you’ll notice strategica navigation bar, optimized sections, custom pages, side bars, sections, and homepage messaging that helps convert visitors to subscribers.
In my reasearch and through interactions with my community’s content, I realized that most creators are under-utilizing these features. Or worse yet, they don’t even know what’s possible.
The Setup Most Creators Never Optimize
I look at a lot of publications because it helps me stay up to date on what’s working, and one thing I noticed is that many creators set up their newsletter with just the basics, figure out how to publish posts, then never dive into their settings to explore what else is possible.
They're running newsletters on default settings with generic messaging and missing the most exciting features specifically designed to help them generate revenue, increase conversions, and get discovered by new audiences.
Meanwhile, the creators making consistent money aren't necessarily the ones with the biggest audiences. They're the ones who know these features exist and have taken the time to optimize them.
What Months of Testing Taught Me
Since optimizing my substack, I've seen exponential growth.
I'm now making more sales, and getting subscribers from Google, Claude, Perplexity, LinkedIn, and other search platforms because my content is organized strategically and my publication is formatted for conversions.
My homepage converts better because different visitors see different messages based on their subscriber status. My navigation bar drives people directly to my offers instead of letting them get lost in my archive.
You don’t have to do everything at once (I sure didn’t), but by making small changes each week, you’ll start to see a compounding effect over time.
What I Started Noticing Everywhere
The more I got into optimizing my own publication, the more I noticed when other Substack creators had overlooked some important features.
I'd visit a creator's homepage and see the basic subscribe button with a generic messaging. Or I'd check their navigation and find only the standard Home, Archive, About pages with no links to their actual offers.
Some of them had thousands of subscribers but were making it unnecessarily hard for people to buy from them.
Others had great content but were invisible to search engines because they hadn't organized their publication strategically.
It became obvious which creators had taken the time to optimize and which ones were still running on the setup they'd created in their first twenty minutes on the platform.
The Gap I Keep Seeing
From what I saw in my study, there's a huge gap between creators who know about and use these features and those who don't.
The ones who've optimized their publications are getting more conversions, more search traffic, and clearer pathways from content to revenue. The ones not optimizing are working harder for the fewer results.
Most creators fall into the second category - not because they're lazy, but because they simply don't know what's possible.
The Features You're Probably Not Using
There are at least a dozen features most creators never touch, including:
Ways to create special offers with urgency.
Options for building custom pages that showcase testimonials and services.
Tools for getting your content discovered off-platform.
Each optimization seems minor by itself. But together, they turn a basic newsletter into a powerful conversion system.
What This Means for Your Revenue
What bothers me most is that these features exist to help creators make more money. But most of us never find them because we set up our publication in 30 minutes and move on.
Every day that your Substack runs on default settings, you're missing:
Revenue from visitors who can't find your offers
Subscriptions from people who can't navigate your content
Search traffic because your content isn't optimized
Conversion opportunities from unclear or generic messaging
Authority building from scattered social proof
The cost adds up fast.
What I'm Sharing Tuesday
I documented everything I discovered during my settings deep-dive. All the features most creators never touch, why they matter for revenue, and how to set them up correctly.
Some of these optimizations take five minutes. Others require more planning. But every one of them is designed to help you make more money and grow your subscriber base.
The difference between a default Substack setup and an optimized one is the difference between hoping visitors figure out how to buy from you and making it impossible for them to miss your offers.
Ready to stop missing revenue opportunities?
Tuesday's deep-dive covers the top 12 features I discovered that could be generating income right now. You'll get the complete setup guide, step-by-step instructions, and the specific optimizations that have the biggest impact on conversion rates.
Plus, I'm sharing which features matter most for small audiences and the common setup mistakes that kill conversions before they start.
Upgrade to access the complete feature guide →
Already a paid member? Tuesday's complete setup guide is waiting in your inbox.
Upgrade to access the complete feature guide →
Already a paid member? Tuesday's complete setup guide will be waiting in your inbox.
Quick Poll
Quick question: Have you ever gone through all your Substack settings, or are you running on the same setup from day one? Reply and let me know—I'm curious how many others are in the same boat I was.
Join the Chat for real-time Substack tips and support →
